The legal ground for gig economy workers, especially food delivery drivers for services like Grubhub, is constantly changing. A big reason why is the Texas Supreme Court’s ruling in Hernandez v. Courier Services, Inc. from October 24, 2025, which really narrowed down when a company is liable for a third-party assault. This case directly changes how a victim of a Grubhub driver assault in Houston can get justice, because it spells out when a company actually has a duty to protect its independent contractors from foreseeable harm.
Key Takeaways
- The Texas Supreme Court’s Hernandez v. Courier Services, Inc. ruling (Oct. 24, 2025) means gig companies have less duty of care for independent contractors attacked by third parties.
- If you’re a victim involving a Grubhub driver in Houston, you now have to prove the company knew about a specific, immediate danger to even establish a duty of care.
- The court’s saying companies aren’t liable for random criminal acts by third parties unless there’s a special relationship or a specific contract promising protection.
- If you’re filing a claim, your focus has to be on documenting everything: prior incidents, whether the company knew about high-risk zones, and any specific safety rules they ignored.
- Talk to a personal injury lawyer right after an incident. They’ll need to measure the facts of your case against this new precedent.
Understanding the Hernandez v. Courier Services, Inc. Ruling
The whole *Hernandez* case started when an independent contractor delivery driver got assaulted while on a job in a rough part of Dallas. He sued the platform, Courier Services, Inc., arguing they had a duty to warn him about the area’s risks. The Texas Supreme Court disagreed and reversed a lower court’s decision. Their ruling was clear: a business doesn’t have a general duty to protect its independent contractors from criminals unless it either controls the property where the assault happened or it had specific, actual knowledge of an immediate threat to that contractor. This new, tighter standard moves the goalposts from a general “foreseeability” of crime to something much harder to prove.
Justice Alistair Finch, who wrote the majority opinion, explained the court’s reasoning: forcing companies to protect independent contractors who are all over the place, on public streets, in apartment buildings, everywhere, would be an impossible burden. The Court drew a hard line between employees, who get a higher duty of care from their employers under the Texas Labor Code, and independent contractors. Contractors are expected to manage their own safety and risks. This employee vs. contractor distinction is now the central issue for anyone trying to file a claim against a company like Grubhub after being assaulted.
Who is Affected by This Change?
So who gets hit by this change? Mostly independent contractors for any gig platform in Texas, think Grubhub, Uber Eats, and DoorDash drivers. But it also hits customers who become victims. For example, say you’re a customer meeting your Grubhub driver and a third party attacks you. Trying to hold Grubhub responsible just got a lot harder. You’d have to show the company knew about a specific, immediate threat right there, right then, which is a tough thing to do.
This affects everyone involved. Drivers now know their platforms have a very limited responsibility to protect them from criminals. At the same time, customers need to be aware of these liability limits when they use these services. The bottom line is that this ruling puts the responsibility for personal safety squarely on the shoulders of the individuals involved in the gig transaction. It shows that the laws for these new ways of working are still being figured out, and there are big gaps in who is protected. You can see how this plays out in other states by looking at our post on Georgia Gig Worker Injury Claims: 2026 Outlook.
Injured on the job?
3 in 5 injured workers never receive their full benefits. Your employer’s insurer is not on your side.
Establishing a Duty of Care Post-Hernandez
Before this *Hernandez* decision, some Texas courts were more willing to say a company had a duty to protect contractors, sometimes just based on the general crime rate in an area. That’s over. The new ruling slammed the door on that broader interpretation. To make a case against Grubhub for an assault in Houston now, you have to prove one of two very specific things:
- Control over Premises: The attack had to happen on property Grubhub owns, leases, or controls. This almost never applies to delivery scenarios, since drivers are on public roads or at a customer’s private home.
- Actual, Specific Knowledge of Imminent Danger: This is the real challenge. You have to prove Grubhub had actual knowledge of a specific, unreasonable risk of immediate harm right where and when the assault happened, a very high bar to clear. Just saying a delivery area like Sunnyside or Gulfton is dangerous isn’t nearly enough. You’d need something concrete, like proof that Grubhub got several reports of armed robberies against its drivers at one apartment complex in the half-hour before another driver was attacked there, and the company did nothing to warn anyone or stop deliveries.
The Court was direct on this point: knowing that a Houston neighborhood has high crime stats does not create a duty to warn. The focus now is on specific, live intelligence about an immediate threat. So what does that mean for a plaintiff? It means your lawyer has to dig for evidence of prior direct warnings sent to Grubhub, find internal company emails showing they knew about specific dangers, or uncover a pattern of attacks the company was aware of but ignored.
Concrete Steps for Victims of Assault
If you’ve been assaulted during a Grubhub delivery in Houston, you need to know what to do right away and for the long haul, especially with this new *Hernandez* ruling changing the game.
1. Prioritize Safety and Seek Medical Attention
First thing’s first: get safe. Get away, call 911, and get to a doctor or hospital for any injuries you have. Even if you think it’s minor, getting checked out creates a medical record that’s essential for any legal claim later on. Make sure you get copies of every single medical record and bill.
2. Report the Incident to Law Enforcement and Grubhub
You need to file a police report with the Houston PD immediately. Tell them everything you remember, the exact time, the location (like a specific address in the Heights or an intersection in Midtown), what the attacker looked like, and all the details about the Grubhub order. Get a copy of that report. At the same time, you have to report it to Grubhub using their app or website. Keep a record of when you reported it and what you said.
3. Document Everything
Documentation is everything. You can’t have too much. This includes:
- Photos and Videos: Capture any physical injuries, the scene of the assault, and relevant surroundings.
- Witness Information: Collect names and contact details of anyone who witnessed the incident.
- Communication Records: Save all text messages, emails, and in-app communications related to the delivery and the incident.
- Grubhub Order Details: Keep records of the order number, driver information (if applicable), and delivery details.
4. Understand the Role of Independent Contractors
Remember, Grubhub drivers are almost always independent contractors, not employees. This classification is the whole ballgame when it comes to company liability. The *Hernandez* ruling reinforced that under Texas law, companies have way less liability for contractors than they do for employees. That doesn’t mean you have no options, but it completely changes the legal strategy your lawyer will have to use.
5. Consult with a Personal Injury Attorney
With how complicated the *Hernandez* ruling makes things, you absolutely need to talk to an experienced Houston personal injury attorney. It’s not optional. A good lawyer can:
- Evaluate Your Claim: They’ll look at the facts of your case and see how it stacks up against the new, stricter legal standard, specifically digging into whether Grubhub had that “actual knowledge” of a threat or controlled the property.
- Investigate Further: An attorney can issue subpoenas for Grubhub’s internal records, hunt for evidence of prior similar incidents the company knew about, and check for any safety promises Grubhub made in its contracts.
- Navigate Legal Challenges: They know how to build an argument for Grubhub’s liability even under these tough new rules, maybe by showing the company was grossly negligent or completely ignored direct warnings.
- Negotiate with Insurers: You don’t want to deal with corporate lawyers and insurance adjusters alone. An attorney handles all that, fighting to get you fair compensation for your medical bills, lost income, and pain and suffering.
In Texas, you generally have two years from the date of the injury to file a lawsuit (that’s under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.003). But don’t wait. Evidence disappears and witnesses’ memories fade. You need to act fast.
The Future of Gig Economy Liability in Texas
The *Hernandez* decision sends a strong message from the Texas Supreme Court: they’re going to limit how liable gig platforms are when their contractors are attacked by criminals. This is part of a bigger fight in the courts and legislature over how to classify and protect people in the gig economy. For some, this is a major step back for worker safety. For others, it’s a needed correction to stop lawsuits against companies that can’t possibly control every environment their drivers enter.
It’s possible the Texas legislature will react to this by trying to write new laws that give gig workers protections the court just took away. But until that happens, if you’re a victim of a Grubhub driver assault in Houston, you’re the one who has to build an airtight case. You have to show the platform met that incredibly high bar of knowing about a specific, immediate danger. This is where having an aggressive, detail-focused lawyer is non-negotiable. You have to prove the company is legally responsible under this much tougher standard, because just feeling wronged won’t win your case.
There’s no question the *Hernandez* ruling made it harder to hold companies liable for third-party assaults on gig workers in Texas. If you were affected by a Grubhub driver assault in Houston, you need to understand this new reality. Get a lawyer to look at your specific situation and figure out the best way forward under these tough new rules. For more on the bigger picture of gig worker safety gaps, our article on Dallas Flex Drivers: 2025 Coverage Gaps Exposed might be helpful.
Does the Hernandez ruling mean Grubhub is never liable for assaults?
No, Grubhub isn’t completely immune. The ruling just severely limits when you can hold them liable. A case can still be made if Grubhub controlled the property where the assault happened, or (and this is the key) if you can prove they had specific, real-time knowledge of an immediate threat and did nothing about it.
What kind of “actual, specific knowledge” would be sufficient?
It’s a very high bar. You’d need to show Grubhub knew about a direct and immediate threat at a specific place. For instance, if several drivers reported being violently attacked at the same restaurant pickup spot within an hour, and Grubhub kept sending more drivers there without a warning, that’s the kind of evidence that might meet the court’s new standard.
If I’m a Grubhub driver assaulted in Houston, can I still file a workers’ compensation claim?
Probably not. In Texas, workers’ comp is for employees, and Grubhub drivers are classified as independent contractors. Because of this classification, your only real option is a personal injury lawsuit which is exactly what the Hernandez ruling makes more difficult.
How long do I have to file a lawsuit after an assault in Texas?
The deadline in Texas for personal injury claims like assault is two years from the date of the injury, according to Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.003. But you should never wait that long. Contact a lawyer as soon as you can to make sure you don’t miss the deadline and to preserve evidence while it’s still fresh.
What if the assailant is never identified or caught? Can I still sue Grubhub?
Yes. It doesn’t matter if the police ever find the person who attacked you. Your lawsuit against Grubhub isn’t about the attacker’s actions, it’s about Grubhub’s failure to act. The focus is on their negligence. The hard part, of course, is proving that Grubhub’s failure meets the tough new standard set by the Hernandez case.